Faith Works 11-27-2026
Jeff Gill
A little comedy, a great deal of wisdom
___
John Mulaney is a writer and comedian whose name has been associated with Saturday Night Live, and he recently came back as host.
I don’t often reference SNL here, and I avoid profanity in my public role and as much as I can privately, which means I don’t talk about sketches on that show really ever as a minister.
But he is widely acknowledged to have hit a social commentary home run with the sketch “Sister” which landed at exactly the right time. Yes, it does have one cuss word in it (you’ve been warned) which is pretty low for that show… and I say with great caution that it is warranted, in context, which I will explain before we close this.
“Sister” is a riff on ads you happen to see quite often at exactly this time of year, and I have written about this more than once in previous Novembers. The adult children go home for Thanksgiving or Christmas, and realize things for elderly parents are worse than they had been. What to do?
As the title suggests, the comic ad offers us the solution of calling “Sister” who will drop everything, including their jobs or family elsewhere, and move in. Yes, yes, yes, there are males who do this. Hi, my name is Jeff, and I’ve been the caregiver. Some people said in the aftermath of “Sister” it was unfairly suggesting only women do this work, and entirely because of societal expectations, and I think they missed the point.
The reality is a) it is usually women who are expected by all and sundry to do this, and b) society isn’t terribly supportive in practical terms of anyone who makes life changes to care for elderly family members. We could debate the reasons for why personal care and hygiene has been considered “women’s work” but the reality is we see it as such, and it puts many working women, often with children of their own who still need their care, in a terrible bind.
You can find the skit online easily enough and decide for yourself. I think it is a very effective call to the very wide audience that’s aware of the reality of this issue to talk to each other about what’s to be done. Yes, there’s that one profanity (a “b-word” if that helps), and any of us who’ve cared for people with cognitive issues and dementia knows people start talking differently than they had their entire lives. Including some honesty that can come out of nowhere, insights which can land painfully, and curse words at the most unexpected moments. It’s part of why so many good, loving children can’t handle doing the personal care of a declining parent. You get whiplash.
Add in the reality that sometimes the parent needing care is not always the one you’d expect, and assumptions about who would do what can get upended by reality in the blink of an eye.
Social media had a number of people saying there must be more women in the writers room at SNL, but the interesting truth is the “Sister” sketch was written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell, two middle-aged guys. I suspect they have stories to tell of their own experiences.
Finally, we still have not entirely sorted out the elderly parent dilemma highlighted during the recent governor’s race. Politics aside, what’s to be done when a problematic older relative, who has done harm in decades past, inflicted pain both emotional and even physical, becomes frail and in need of assistance? Who is responsible? How does that work? And if you say “Medicaid will take care of it…” I have another long column for you, perhaps on another day.
Jeff Gill is a writer, storyteller, and preacher in central Ohio; he’s got some caregiver experience. Tell him about how you decided things in your family at knapsack77@gmail.com, or follow @Knapsack on X.
Jeff Gill
A little comedy, a great deal of wisdom
___
John Mulaney is a writer and comedian whose name has been associated with Saturday Night Live, and he recently came back as host.
I don’t often reference SNL here, and I avoid profanity in my public role and as much as I can privately, which means I don’t talk about sketches on that show really ever as a minister.
But he is widely acknowledged to have hit a social commentary home run with the sketch “Sister” which landed at exactly the right time. Yes, it does have one cuss word in it (you’ve been warned) which is pretty low for that show… and I say with great caution that it is warranted, in context, which I will explain before we close this.
“Sister” is a riff on ads you happen to see quite often at exactly this time of year, and I have written about this more than once in previous Novembers. The adult children go home for Thanksgiving or Christmas, and realize things for elderly parents are worse than they had been. What to do?
As the title suggests, the comic ad offers us the solution of calling “Sister” who will drop everything, including their jobs or family elsewhere, and move in. Yes, yes, yes, there are males who do this. Hi, my name is Jeff, and I’ve been the caregiver. Some people said in the aftermath of “Sister” it was unfairly suggesting only women do this work, and entirely because of societal expectations, and I think they missed the point.
The reality is a) it is usually women who are expected by all and sundry to do this, and b) society isn’t terribly supportive in practical terms of anyone who makes life changes to care for elderly family members. We could debate the reasons for why personal care and hygiene has been considered “women’s work” but the reality is we see it as such, and it puts many working women, often with children of their own who still need their care, in a terrible bind.
You can find the skit online easily enough and decide for yourself. I think it is a very effective call to the very wide audience that’s aware of the reality of this issue to talk to each other about what’s to be done. Yes, there’s that one profanity (a “b-word” if that helps), and any of us who’ve cared for people with cognitive issues and dementia knows people start talking differently than they had their entire lives. Including some honesty that can come out of nowhere, insights which can land painfully, and curse words at the most unexpected moments. It’s part of why so many good, loving children can’t handle doing the personal care of a declining parent. You get whiplash.
Add in the reality that sometimes the parent needing care is not always the one you’d expect, and assumptions about who would do what can get upended by reality in the blink of an eye.
Social media had a number of people saying there must be more women in the writers room at SNL, but the interesting truth is the “Sister” sketch was written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell, two middle-aged guys. I suspect they have stories to tell of their own experiences.
Finally, we still have not entirely sorted out the elderly parent dilemma highlighted during the recent governor’s race. Politics aside, what’s to be done when a problematic older relative, who has done harm in decades past, inflicted pain both emotional and even physical, becomes frail and in need of assistance? Who is responsible? How does that work? And if you say “Medicaid will take care of it…” I have another long column for you, perhaps on another day.
Jeff Gill is a writer, storyteller, and preacher in central Ohio; he’s got some caregiver experience. Tell him about how you decided things in your family at knapsack77@gmail.com, or follow @Knapsack on X.

No comments:
Post a Comment